The Best Dog Crate Pans & Trays in 2024
Is the tray in your dog’s crate in pretty poor shape? Maybe its bent, stained, scratched, or warped. You won’t need to purchase a whole new crate for your dog; you’ll be able to purchase just a new crate pan.
To help you determine which pan or tray you’ll want to purchase, we have reviewed five of the top options below. Read through our reviews to help you find the right product for your dog’s crate.
Our Top 5 List
Last update on 2024-09-14 at 08:30 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
1. Replacement Pan for Midwest Crates
The pan is designed to be used with MidWest crates, but also fits in other crates that are a standard size. We find it to be durable and easy to clean.
It is made from an odor-resistant polypropylene plastic. For easier clean-up, it can be slid out of the crate in the event your dog has an accident on it. You can purchase this one in multiple size options to accommodate crates of different sizes. It is available in 18-inch, 22-inch, 24-inch, 30-inch, 36-inch, 42-inch, 48-inch, and 54-inch sizes.
In addition to using this pan in a crate, you can also use it as a food and water mat, placed under a cat’s litter box to catch excess litter, or put in a mudroom to hold shoes. You’ll find so many different options for using it that you may want to get two trays.
2. Replacement Plastic Tray
This one has a deep lip that is designed to contain messes and prevent them from spilling out of the crate onto your floors. If your dog does make a mess on their tray, you’ll be able to clean it easily. The tray can be wiped down with a damp cloth and soap, scrubbed with a brush for stubborn stains, or even hosed down outside when you really don’t want to get near the mess your dog made.
This option is lightweight, yet durable. It is made from a heavy-duty ABS plastic that will help the tray last for a long time. You can purchase this tray in five different sizes: 20-inches, 24-inches, 30-inche, 42-inches, or 48-inches. It should fit in most standard crates of these sizes.
3. Pinnacle Systems Metal Tray
If your dog has been chewing through the plastic tray that came with their crate, you’ll definitely want to consider this metal tray. Using this option will avoid your dog breaking through a plastic tray and ingesting pieces of plastic or cutting himself on a sharp edge.
This tray can be purchased with a stainless-steel or galvanized steel finish. Whichever option you select, you can be confident that you purchased a quality product that will last a long time. Both the stainless-steel and galvanized steel trays are rust-proof, water-resistant, and will resist wear and tear better than many plastic options.
This product also includes a lifetime guarantee. The manufacturer will refund your money if you decide you are not satisfied with your purchase.
You can purchase this tray in seven different sizes: 35.5 inches by 23.25 inches by 1 inch, 35.38 inches by 21.88 inches by 1 inch, 35 inches by 21.63 inches by 1 inch, 41inches by 26 inches by 1 inch, 41 inches by 27.38 inches by 1 inch, 47 inches by 27 inches by 1 inch, and 47 inches by 29.13 inches by 1 inch.
4. Pinnacle Systems Metal Pan
This one offers different size options designed to fit some popular crate brands. You can find sizes that will fit the Precision Pet 36-inch crate and the MidWest 36-inch iCrate. There are also a variety of other sizes available to fit other brands of crates with standard measurements.
This metal pan is available with a galvanized steel or stainless-steel finish. Since it is made from metal, you dog won’t be able to chew of pieces of plastic that could become choking hazards. The rust-proof metal construction will help this product last for a very long time.
The manufacturer of this product is so confident in its quality that they offer a lifetime guarantee. They will refund your money if you are not satisfied with your purchase.
5. You & Me Plastic Replacement Pan
No products found.
This is a plastic pan with beveled edges designed to hold in any messes and prevent them from leaking over onto your floors. It has a non-slip surface, so you’ll be able to put a blanket or other bedding in the crate for your dog without worrying about it getting all bunched up.
If this pan gets dirty, you can clean it up easily with just a bit of soap and water. There are three different size options to choose from: extra-small, small, and medium. The extra-small size measures 17 inches by 11.7 inches by 1 inch, the small size measures 24 inches by 16.9 inches by 1 inch, and the medium size measures 30 inches by 18.9 inches by 1 inch.
Verdict & Review
Replacement Pan for Midwest Crate
Pros
- Good material
- Sturdy
- All needed size options
- You can use it as a food & water mat
- Fits non-Midwest crates that have standard sizes
Cons
- We haven't encountered any cons.
After conducting our reviews above and comparing the different options, we have concluded that the MidWest pan is our favorite option. You’ll be satisfied with your purchase of this product for a variety of reasons.
First, you’ll find that this pan is very durable. It is made from a heavy-duty polypropylene plastic that is designed to last for a long time. This material choice also helps to make the crate tray easy to clean.
There are a variety of sizes available that will fit crates ranging from 18 inches to 54 inches. You’ll also be able to find a variety of other uses for this pan around your house, included holding shoes in your mudroom or catching litter from a litter box.
Buying Guide
Having a sturdy and easy to clean pan in your dog’s crate is important. It can help protect your floors and make it much easier to clean up messes.
Unfortunately, the pans that come with the crates we purchase don’t always last as long as the rest of the crate. Fortunately, we are able to purchase a new pan instead of having to pay for a completely new crate. Since not all pans are exactly alike, read through our buying guide below to help you decide what you’re looking for in the product you choose.
Size
When purchasing a new pan or tray, it is essential to find a product that is the right size. You need the pan to fit exactly – if it is too big, it won’t go in at all, and if it is too small, there will be too much of the crate and your floor that is left unprotected. Plus, your dog will have less space or will end up uncomfortable if they lay on the sides of the pan.
Lip
Another thing you want to see in a pan is a decent lip around the edges. The lip will help keep any messes your dog makes in the crate, instead of letting them seep off the edges onto your floors. You’ll find clean up much easier when your dog does make a mess if you select a pan that has at least a one-inch lip.
Materials
You will also want to pay close attention to the materials used to make the pan. Most pans are either made from an ABS plastic, a polypropylene plastic, or metal. If your dog doesn’t chew on their crate pad, any of the materials should be fine.
However, if your dog has been known to chew on or destroy their pad, you may want to consider a metal option, such as stainless-steel. This material choice will be more durable and less likely to get broken by your dog. You also won’t need to worry about your dog eating bits of plastic or getting cut by a sharp corner they made by chewing.
Care and Cleaning
Finally, be sure to pick a material that is easy to clean. You’ll want to be able to wipe down minor messes with some soap and water, and may want to have the option to hose down the tray if your dog makes a really big mess. Look carefully at the care and cleaning directions for each product before you make a purchase.
FAQ
Do I need a crate pan?
Yes, you will want to make sure the crate has a pan or tray. The pan helps to keep the rest of the crate cleaner by catching any messes your dog makes. You’ll find it much easier to wipe of a smooth pan than trying to clean a wire crate.
A pan also provides your dog with a solid surface to sleep on. Compared to the textured feel of sleeping on the wire grates, their pan is much more comfortable. However, you still may want to look for a mat to keep them even more comfortable.
Are plastic or metal pans better?
Depending on your dog, both plastic and metal pans can be perfectly fine. However, if your dog is a chewer, you may want to go with a metal option. Your dog won’t be able to chew through a metal pan. Conversely, if they chew on a plastic pan, they could break off a piece. This could create sharp edges on the tray, or they may even ingest the piece of plastic they broke off.
If you choose a metal pan, look for options such as galvanized steel or stainless steel. These options are rust-resistant, so they won’t create rust that could be hazardous to your dog’s health.
We are the Pet Dog Pals, a group of avid pet owners, bloggers, product testers, and writers for all your canine needs! We own a collective 16 dogs and 21 cats to help us test and review pet products. Our top lists and tips come from experience to help you be the best dog owner you can be!